From Illegal Business to Cybercrime Aiding: The Shifting Landscape of Crypto OTC Prosecutions in China
A recent criminal case in China has spotlighted the evolving legal strategies prosecutors use against over-the-counter (OTC) cryptocurrency traders. A client engaged in USDT OTC trading had a bank card frozen after receiving RMB from an underground banking chain. Police initially investigated the individual for illegal business operations, but during the prosecution review, the evidence proved insufficient. Rather than dropping the case, authorities pivoted to charging the suspect with aiding information network criminal activities (helping cybercrime), a lesser but still serious offense.
The Legal Maneuver: From Illegal Business to Cybercrime Aiding
The charge of illegal business operations typically applies to unlicensed financial activities, but it requires proof that the defendant knowingly operated without a license. In this case, the evidence chain was weak. However, prosecutors noticed that the suspect’s other bank cards had previously received funds linked to online fraud, prompting them to invoke the crime of aiding information network criminal activities. This charge, introduced in 2015, targets those who provide technical support or payment facilitation for cybercrimes. Its broad wording allows prosecutors to pursue cases even when the primary crime is not clearly established.
This shift reflects a broader trend in China’s judicial approach to crypto-related crimes. As the government maintains a strict ban on crypto trading and initial coin offerings, law enforcement agencies are increasingly using flexible charges to secure convictions. The aiding cybercrime charge has become a catch-all for individuals involved in crypto transactions, especially those who may unknowingly facilitate illicit flows.
Implications for Crypto Traders and the Industry
The case underscores the legal risks faced by OTC traders in China. Even if they are not directly involved in illegal activities, their bank accounts can be frozen, and they can face criminal charges if funds are traced to illicit sources. This has a chilling effect on the crypto market, driving trading activity underground or to offshore platforms. It also highlights the importance of robust anti-money laundering (AML) compliance for crypto businesses operating in or with China.
For defense lawyers, the case illustrates the need to challenge the evidence chain and argue that the defendant lacked knowledge of the underlying crimes. The shift to aiding cybercrime charges may also open new defense strategies, such as disputing the existence of an upstream cybercrime or arguing that the defendant’s actions were not intentional.
Forward-Looking Perspective
As China continues to tighten its grip on crypto-related activities, we can expect more cases where prosecutors use alternative charges to secure convictions. The legal landscape for crypto in China remains highly uncertain, and market participants must stay vigilant. The case also signals that international cooperation on AML and counter-terrorism financing will be crucial for the global crypto industry. Traders and platforms should enhance their compliance frameworks to mitigate legal risks.




