Federal Appeals Court Sides with Maryland Regulators in Kalshi Case
TREE NEWS reports: The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit has upheld a lower court’s refusal to grant prediction market platform Kalshi a preliminary injunction against Maryland’s enforcement of state gambling laws. In a 2-1 decision, the appellate panel ruled that Maryland regulators can continue to pursue Kalshi for offering sports event contracts without a state sports betting license. The court’s decision, issued Tuesday, comes after Maryland authorities determined in April 2025 that Kalshi was operating illegally and ordered the platform to cease offering such contracts to local users.
The majority opinion, supported by two judges, found that Kalshi had not demonstrated a likelihood of success on the merits of its claim that federal commodities law preempts Maryland’s gambling regulations. One judge dissented, arguing that the platform’s contracts fall under the exclusive jurisdiction of the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC). The ruling represents a significant setback for Kalshi’s efforts to expand its event-contract offerings nationwide without seeking state-level gambling licenses.
Implications for Prediction Markets and Regulatory Boundaries
The case highlights the growing tension between federal derivatives regulation and state gambling laws as prediction markets increasingly offer contracts on sports, elections, and other real-world events. Kalshi, which is regulated by the CFTC as a designated contract market, has argued that its products are financial derivatives, not wagers. However, state regulators contend that sports event contracts are functionally identical to sports betting, which requires a state license.
- Preemption debate intensifies: The Fourth Circuit’s decision adds to a split among federal appeals courts on whether CFTC-regulated event contracts preempt state gambling laws. This increases the likelihood of Supreme Court review.
- Compliance burden grows: Prediction market platforms may need to navigate a patchwork of state licensing regimes, raising operational costs and limiting access for users in restrictive states.
- Market uncertainty: The ruling could chill innovation in event-based derivatives and slow the convergence of traditional finance and decentralized prediction markets.
For the broader crypto and DeFi ecosystem, the outcome underscores the regulatory risks facing platforms that blur the line between financial instruments and gambling. While Kalshi is a centralized, CFTC-regulated entity, its legal battle sets a precedent that could affect decentralized prediction markets and other blockchain-based event contracts seeking to operate across state lines.
What to Watch Next
Kalshi is expected to seek an expedited appeal or petition the Supreme Court to resolve the circuit split. Meanwhile, Maryland’s enforcement action will proceed, potentially resulting in fines or an injunction against Kalshi’s operations in the state. The case also adds pressure on the CFTC to clarify its position on event contracts, as the agency weighs whether to assert broader authority over sports-related derivatives. For now, prediction market operators face a fragmented regulatory landscape, with state gambling regulators increasingly assertive in policing products they view as unlicensed sports betting.




