Goldman Warns of 2018-Style Liquidity Crunch as Fed Tightening Threatens Markets
TREE NEWS reports: Goldman Sachs’ trading head Rich Privorotsky has flagged alarming parallels between current market conditions and the fourth quarter of 2018, when the S&P 500 plunged nearly 20% from its September peak to its Christmas Eve low, forcing the Federal Reserve to abandon its tightening cycle. In a Friday report, Privorotsky described the recent selloff as “across-the-board liquidation” rather than ordinary sector rotation, warning that markets may be transitioning from risk-aversion to a deeper liquidity contraction.
The comparison is striking. In 2018, the Fed raised rates four times, with the final hike in December pushing the target range to 2.25%–2.50%. The S&P 500 fell 19.8% from its September 20 high to the December 24 low, narrowly missing a technical bear market. The selling pressure ultimately forced the Fed to signal a pause in January 2019, triggering a sharp rebound. Today, investors face a similar dilemma: the Fed is still expected to tighten further, even as financial conditions tighten rapidly and growth prospects dim.
Financial Conditions Tightening at Alarming Pace
Privorotsky points to the Goldman Sachs US Financial Conditions Index (FCI) macro basket, which rose to 124.48 on Thursday—the highest level in a year—after climbing about 8 points in just two weeks since early November. The S&P 500 fell 2% on Thursday despite being up more than 1% intraday, marking its sixth consecutive decline and closing below its 200-day moving average. All 11 sectors ended lower, including traditional defensive plays like utilities and consumer staples.
Fed officials have amplified concerns. Governor Waller’s comment about a potential 50-basis-point hike, along with meeting minutes showing support for further tightening, have intensified market anxiety. Rising capital costs are also pressuring return expectations for AI infrastructure investments. Privorotsky notes that technical damage is severe, with negative gamma effects in the options market amplifying the downturn.
Gold: The Key Liquidity Gauge
What worries Privorotsky most is gold’s unusual behavior. Typically a safe haven, gold has fallen alongside equities, dropping below $3,600 per ounce, while copper plunged about 5% in a single day. This synchronized cross-asset decline signals that investors are not merely rotating from stocks to gold but selling across asset classes to raise cash—a hallmark of broader liquidity stress.
ANZ estimates that speculative long positions in gold could still be reduced by about 200 tonnes, suggesting deleveraging pressure may not be fully exhausted. Meanwhile, long-term Treasury yields are falling and inflation breakeven rates are contracting, even as stocks and gold sell off. Privorotsky interprets this combination as a shift in market focus from inflation to growth and liquidity concerns, with bond markets potentially pricing in a policy error. Whether gold stabilizes will be a critical window to gauge whether liquidity pressure is easing.
When Will the Fed Pivot?
Privorotsky believes the scale of pessimism and one-sided deleveraging suggests markets may be approaching a tactical low. With fund positioning already significantly underweight, any rebound catalyst could produce a violent rally. However, a true turning point depends on a shift in policy expectations. He remains bullish on short-term Treasuries, arguing that this trade is markedly at odds with the risk signals emanating from equities.
Upcoming data—PCE, nonfarm payrolls, and the December FOMC meeting—will be closely watched. But Privorotsky argues that the November CPI report, though still some time away, is the data point most likely to force the Fed to reassess its policy path. Notably, Goldman economists still expect a 25-basis-point hike in December and another in March 2027, a forecast that bond markets are clearly disputing.
Key Takeaways for Investors
- Liquidity stress is mounting: The shift from sector rotation to broad liquidation and the simultaneous selloff in stocks and gold suggest a deeper liquidity crunch may be unfolding.
- Gold is the tell: Watch gold’s price action as a real-time indicator of liquidity conditions. A sustained breakdown could signal worsening stress; stabilization could mark a tactical bottom.
- Policy divergence is key: The Fed’s hawkish stance versus market pricing of a pause creates a fragile backdrop. A dovish pivot—likely triggered by weaker inflation or growth data—could spark a powerful rally.
- Positioning is stretched: With investors already underweight equities, any positive catalyst could lead to sharp short-covering. However, timing the turn remains hazardous.




