Press Enter to search · ESC to close

US Stocks

Goldman Sachs Trader Revives 2018 Playbook: US Stock Selloff May Not Be Over

Goldman Sachs derivatives strategist Brian Garrett warns that the current US stock selloff resembles the 2018 fourth-quarter rout, with the S&P 500 only 42% through the 2018 decline and a bottom potentially not until January. Credit markets and the Fed have not yet signaled the reversal conditions seen in 2018, so any rebound may be temporary.

Goldman Sachs Trader Revives 2018 Playbook: US Stock Selloff May Not Be Over

US stocks have fallen for seven consecutive sessions, and a Goldman Sachs derivatives trader is warning that the current market is showing striking similarities to the fourth-quarter 2018 rout, suggesting the correction may not be finished. In a report released Friday, derivatives strategist Brian Garrett pointed to parallels in price action, technicals, and market microstructure, and compared the drawdowns of major indices to gauge how much further they could fall.

Garrett recalled the market crash on December 24, 2018, when a client asked him why stocks were falling so sharply. “I had absolutely no idea,” he admitted. Even seasoned traders struggled to pinpoint the cause of the sudden selloff. But historical parallels do not guarantee a repeat. This time, credit markets have not deteriorated significantly, and the Federal Reserve has not signaled a policy pivot. Goldman sees these differences as key to judging whether the current pullback is nearing an end.

How Much Further?

Goldman compared the decline in major indices from their October 6 peak to the same period in 2018. As of Thursday’s close, the S&P 500 had completed 42% of the 2018 decline, the Nasdaq 100 69%, and the Russell 2000 just 24%. If the remaining 2018 losses are mapped onto the current market, Goldman’s model suggests further downside for major indices. The S&P 500 has not yet matched its 2018 decline, implying downside risk remains.

In terms of timing, the 2018 S&P 500 took 65 trading days to go from its peak to its ultimate trough. As of Friday, the current correction has lasted about 33 trading days. If the pace is similar, a bottom may not arrive until the first full trading week of January.

Credit Markets Lag, Fed Not Pivoting

Compared with 2018, stress in credit markets is noticeably lighter. Investment-grade credit spreads have widened only 5 basis points from their recent low, while high-yield spreads have widened 38 basis points—both well below the moves seen in 2018. Interest-rate markets have also not shown the same flight to safety: the 10-year swap rate is down 23 basis points from its recent high, with smaller moves at the short end. This suggests the market has not fully repriced the economic and policy outlook as it did in 2018.

A key catalyst for the 2018 reversal was then-Fed Chair Jerome Powell’s “patient” signal on January 4. Now, Goldman economists still expect the Fed to raise rates again in March, and policy expectations have not shifted toward easing. Barclays also noted that investors see no possibility of a Fed backstop.

Safe Havens Fail, Panic Rises

Traditional safe-haven assets have not worked this time. Since the recent peak, gold has fallen 10.8% and the yen has weakened about 1% against the dollar. In the same period of 2018, gold rose 5% and the yen appreciated 2.1%. The divergence is stark.

Panic is rising. Goldman’s volatility team rated current market fear at 9 out of 10, with the VIX at 30.3—not far from the 36.1 peak seen just before Christmas 2018—even though the S&P 500 has fallen less than half as much. Market structure is amplifying moves: Goldman estimates dealers hold about $1 billion in net short gamma, which could intensify hedging sells during declines. Clients have started selling high-premium tail options, reflecting a shift in volatility strategies.

Dispersion is also extreme. Nvidia has tumbled about 39% since early October. Among 2,258 baskets tracked by Goldman, those that performed well in the first half have generally retraced in the second half; baskets that more than doubled in the first half have seen median returns of about -50% in the second half. Previously crowded winning trades are being unwound.

Rebound May Be Borrowed

Conditions for a short-term bounce exist: positioning has been cleaned out, fear gauges are near extremes, some clients are selling volatility, and the Nasdaq 100 is nearing oversold territory. Historically, the S&P 500 has seen short-term rebounds after breaking below its 200-day moving average, and the holiday-shortened week could offer relief.

But a short-term bounce does not mean a bottom. Before the 2018 reversal, credit spreads widened significantly and the Fed signaled a policy shift; neither condition is present now. Garrett believes any rebound is “borrowed” until credit markets deteriorate or the Fed changes stance. Investors need clearer signals from credit risk and monetary policy before calling the end of this correction.

Key Takeaways

  • Goldman’s derivatives desk sees the current selloff echoing 2018, with the S&P 500 only 42% through the 2018 drawdown and a potential bottom not until January.
  • Credit spreads and rate markets are calmer than in 2018, and the Fed has not pivoted—two missing pieces that could mark the end of the correction.
  • Safe-haven assets are failing, panic is elevated, and dealer short gamma may amplify volatility; crowded winners are being sold aggressively.
  • Short-term rebounds are possible, but without credit deterioration or a Fed shift, they may be temporary. Watch credit spreads and Fed rhetoric closely.

View original

Share
Risk notice This site provides news and information on the crypto, blockchain and Web3 industry for reference only and does not constitute investment advice or any promise of returns. Virtual currency-related activities are illegal financial activities in mainland China; digital asset prices are highly volatile; use at your own risk. This site does not provide trading, token issuance or related referral services.

Related Reading

Latest News

TREE NEWS share card
Long-press image above → Save to Photos / Share
Pitch us Feedback