44 State Attorneys General Push Back Against CFTC Prediction Market Rules
TREE NEWS reports: In a significant escalation of the regulatory turf war over prediction markets, 44 state attorneys general have filed a joint opposition to the Commodity Futures Trading Commission’s (CFTC) proposed rulemaking on event contracts. The coalition argues that the federal agency lacks the legal authority to address gambling-related consumer harms, asserting that such matters fall squarely within the purview of state governments.
The action, co-led by New Jersey Attorney General Jennifer Davenport, contends that the CFTC’s rulemaking attempts to overturn states’ long-standing power to regulate gambling within their borders. “These actions would allow prediction markets to bypass state gambling laws and the safeguards that ensure responsible gaming,” Davenport said in a statement on Friday.
The Core Dispute
At issue is the CFTC’s proposal to regulate prediction markets—platforms where users can bet on the outcomes of events ranging from elections to economic indicators. The agency has been exploring whether such contracts constitute “event contracts” under the Commodity Exchange Act and whether they should be subject to federal oversight. The states, however, see this as a federal overreach into an area traditionally governed by local gambling regulations.
The attorneys general argue that the CFTC’s rulemaking would preempt state laws designed to protect consumers from the harms of gambling, including addiction and fraud. They maintain that the agency’s authority is limited to financial derivatives and does not extend to what they characterize as gambling products.
Implications for Prediction Markets
The outcome of this dispute could have far-reaching consequences for the rapidly growing prediction market sector, which includes platforms like Polymarket and Kalshi. These platforms have gained traction by offering users the ability to trade on real-world events, often blurring the line between financial instruments and gambling.
A federal framework could provide regulatory clarity and potentially expand the market by allowing these platforms to operate nationwide. However, if states prevail, prediction markets could face a patchwork of regulations, limiting their reach and increasing compliance costs.
The CFTC has not yet commented on the attorneys general’s filing. The agency’s rulemaking process is ongoing, and public comments are likely to be considered before any final rule is issued.
Forward-Looking Perspective
This clash highlights the broader tension between federal and state authorities in the rapidly evolving digital asset space. As prediction markets continue to grow, the need for a clear regulatory framework becomes more urgent. The outcome of this dispute will likely set a precedent for how other innovative financial products are regulated, and could influence the development of similar markets in the future.
Industry participants are watching closely, as the resolution could determine whether prediction markets remain a niche offering or become a mainstream financial tool. The CFTC’s final rule, expected in the coming months, will be a key indicator of the regulatory direction.




